Listen to this article in summarized format
Loading...
××
Subscribe to
Unlock AI Briefing and Premium Content
Subscribe NowWhat's Included
- Exclusive Stories
- Daily ePaper Access
- Smart Market Tools
- Curated Investment Ideas
- Ad-lite Experience
Subscription
Social media thrives on sensational history, and few stories have travelled as far as the claim that medieval European women routinely poisoned their husbands every morning and gave them an antidote at night. The idea, which has recently gone viral again, has left millions shocked, amused, and oddly impressed.
But did this practice actually exist, or is it just another internet myth dressed up as history?
A Viral Claim With a Modern Makeover
The story has been circulating online for years, resurfacing every few months with minor changes. As per NDTV, versions of the claim have been traced back to at least 2022, often presented without sources and framed as a “forgotten medieval tradition”.
By 2025, the claim had once again gone viral, collecting millions of views across platforms. Posts suggested that women used slow-acting poisons to ensure their husbands returned home each night for the antidote, supposedly a clever way to prevent infidelity.
However, historians say the very neatness of the story should raise suspicion.
Why History and Science Don’t Support the Claim
According to historical research cited by NDTV, medieval Europe lacked even a basic understanding of toxicology. While certain substances like arsenic and lead were known, controlling their dosage with precision would have been nearly impossible.
One of the most frequently referenced medieval texts on poisons, Liber de venenis by Pietro d’Abano (written in the early 14th century), contains a mix of folklore and unverified claims. It does not describe anything resembling a daily poison-and-antidote routine.
Modern toxicology also contradicts the claim. Repeated exposure to poison usually leads to worsening effects, not controlled illness. The idea that someone could be poisoned daily and remain healthy enough to function normally simply does not align with medical science.
What Historians Actually Say
As per NDTV, historians who have studied the origins of this story found that similar tales appear in much later cultural folklore, not medieval Europe.
Some versions were traced to Chinese and Indian legends recorded centuries after the Middle Ages. Others appear in early 20th-century magazines or oral traditions, often framed as moral warnings rather than historical fact.
Another key source of the modern myth is popular culture. Historians point out that a line from the 2001 French film Brotherhood of the Wolf closely matches the viral claim, suggesting the idea may have spread from fiction rather than fact.
Crucially, no legal records, church writings, medical texts, or court documents from medieval Europe mention such a practice.
Why the Story Keeps Going Viral
The tale survives because it fits modern expectations: secret power, hidden intelligence, and rebellion within a rigid society. It also appeals to the internet’s love for dramatic, bite-sized history.
But as experts cited by NDTV note, real history is rarely so cinematic. The absence of names, locations, or documented cases makes the story more myth than reality.
So, Did It Ever Really Happen?
The answer is simple: no.
While poisoning did occur in history, most famously with figures like Giulia Tofana in 17th-century Italy, there is no evidence that medieval women systematically poisoned and cured their husbands as a daily practice.
The viral claim is best understood as a modern myth built from folklore, pop culture, and misunderstanding of medieval life.
The story may be entertaining, but history tells a quieter, more grounded truth. Medieval Europe had enough dangers without secret household poison rituals. Sometimes, the most dramatic stories are simply the least accurate.
Inputs from agencies
But did this practice actually exist, or is it just another internet myth dressed up as history?
A Viral Claim With a Modern Makeover
The story has been circulating online for years, resurfacing every few months with minor changes. As per NDTV, versions of the claim have been traced back to at least 2022, often presented without sources and framed as a “forgotten medieval tradition”.By 2025, the claim had once again gone viral, collecting millions of views across platforms. Posts suggested that women used slow-acting poisons to ensure their husbands returned home each night for the antidote, supposedly a clever way to prevent infidelity.
However, historians say the very neatness of the story should raise suspicion.
Why History and Science Don’t Support the Claim
According to historical research cited by NDTV, medieval Europe lacked even a basic understanding of toxicology. While certain substances like arsenic and lead were known, controlling their dosage with precision would have been nearly impossible.One of the most frequently referenced medieval texts on poisons, Liber de venenis by Pietro d’Abano (written in the early 14th century), contains a mix of folklore and unverified claims. It does not describe anything resembling a daily poison-and-antidote routine.
Modern toxicology also contradicts the claim. Repeated exposure to poison usually leads to worsening effects, not controlled illness. The idea that someone could be poisoned daily and remain healthy enough to function normally simply does not align with medical science.
What Historians Actually Say
As per NDTV, historians who have studied the origins of this story found that similar tales appear in much later cultural folklore, not medieval Europe.Some versions were traced to Chinese and Indian legends recorded centuries after the Middle Ages. Others appear in early 20th-century magazines or oral traditions, often framed as moral warnings rather than historical fact.
Another key source of the modern myth is popular culture. Historians point out that a line from the 2001 French film Brotherhood of the Wolf closely matches the viral claim, suggesting the idea may have spread from fiction rather than fact.
Crucially, no legal records, church writings, medical texts, or court documents from medieval Europe mention such a practice.
Why the Story Keeps Going Viral
The tale survives because it fits modern expectations: secret power, hidden intelligence, and rebellion within a rigid society. It also appeals to the internet’s love for dramatic, bite-sized history.But as experts cited by NDTV note, real history is rarely so cinematic. The absence of names, locations, or documented cases makes the story more myth than reality.
So, Did It Ever Really Happen?
The answer is simple: no.While poisoning did occur in history, most famously with figures like Giulia Tofana in 17th-century Italy, there is no evidence that medieval women systematically poisoned and cured their husbands as a daily practice.
The viral claim is best understood as a modern myth built from folklore, pop culture, and misunderstanding of medieval life.
The story may be entertaining, but history tells a quieter, more grounded truth. Medieval Europe had enough dangers without secret household poison rituals. Sometimes, the most dramatic stories are simply the least accurate.
Inputs from agencies
