Nearly a month after 84-year-old Nancy Guthrie vanished from her Arizona home, the search for answers appears to be entering a new phase. The Pima County Sheriff's Department has led the investigation from the start. But recent developments suggest the Federal Bureau of Investigation may be preparing to take a more prominent role. A former FBI agent now says several recent decisions are “telling” signs of change.
Since Feb. 1, when Nancy Guthrie was reportedly kidnapped from her home, the Pima County Sheriff’s Department has directed the search effort. Sheriff Chris Nanos previously stated that as many as 400 personnel were assigned to the case at one point, as per a report by Men's Journal.
ALSO READ: Quote of the Day by Ozzy Osbourne: 'Of all the things I've lost I miss my mind the most...'—Inspiring quotes by the 'Prince of Darkness'
However, that level of manpower is now being reduced. On Friday, the department announced that officers who had been reassigned from other units would return to their regular duties. Moving forward, only detectives specifically assigned to Guthrie’s disappearance will continue working the case unless new leads justify another surge in staffing.
ALSO READ: Quote of the Day by Russell Crowe: 'You need to learn to live with your mistakes. And you need...'—Inspiring quotes by the Gladiator actor
“This remains an active investigation and will continue until Nancy Guthrie is located or all leads have been exhausted,” a spokesperson said in a statement. “The Pima County Sheriff’s Department is refocusing resources to detectives specifically assigned to this case. As leads are developed and resolved, resource allocation may fluctuate. PCSD will maintain a patrol presence in the Guthrie neighborhood.”
The decision to scale back comes amid questions and controversy surrounding how the case has been handled. While the department remains committed, the structure of the investigation appears to be shifting, as per a report by Men's Journal.
ALSO READ: Apple March Event 2026: Date, time and how to watch in the US and UK
According to Jennifer Coffindaffer, a retired FBI Special Agent and former SWAT Team member who now contributes to NewsNation, several recent moves suggest that federal authorities may be stepping forward to oversee the case in a task force setting.
Writing on X, Coffindaffer described the developments as “telling,” noting that the public has recently been directed to submit tips directly to the FBI rather than to local authorities. She also pointed out that the case headquarters has been moved to Phoenix.
Another noticeable change, she said, is that Sheriff Nanos has taken more of a backseat when addressing the press, relying instead on press releases and a Public Information Officer.
ALSO READ: Nancy Guthrie investigation takes dramatic turn as retired FBI agent points to a ‘big find’
The most significant moment, in her view, occurred when federal prosecutors accompanied FBI special agents to Guthrie’s home “to continue to support the investigation” into her disappearance. Coffindaffer believes this could signal that federal authorities are asserting a statute stating that if a kidnapped person is not released within 24 hours, it is presumed they may have crossed state lines, as per a report by Men's Journal.
She called the development "great news" and said it is "a pretty darn good indication" that the FBI is taking over the case.
“I think there is a certain amount of incongruency with what has gone on between the sheriff’s office, perhaps, and federal authorities. I think we’re seeing that, and perhaps in some ways, the lack of trust generally in the progress of the case because we are now almost at a month,” Coffindaffer told Newsweek. “It might be time for a change in command and, quite frankly, it might have already happened. When you see the U.S. Attorney’s Office out there, that’s a pretty darn good indication.”
Coffindaffer also indicated on social media that she believes Monday could mark the official shift in leadership.
ALSO READ: Quote of the Day by Elizabeth Taylor: 'You find out who your real friends are when...'—Inspiring quotes by the incredible actor
Even if the FBI formally assumes control, Coffindaffer expects collaboration rather than separation.
"Look for several Pima County officers to be assigned to the task force. They will stay involved, but the overarching case will be the responsibility of the FBI as discussed," Coffindaffer wrote in a post on X.
She further explained to Newsweek that cooperation between federal and local law enforcement is standard practice.
"The FBI does not like to shut out any of their state or local partners, and they're certainly not going to want to do that here. Overall, the bureau wants to work side by side with other law enforcement partners. In Pima County, those officers have the best insight regarding their territory," Coffindaffer told Newsweek.
Nancy Guthrie remains missing as of now. The Pima County Sheriff’s Department continues to call the case active, while developments suggest the FBI’s presence may soon define its next chapter.
A retired FBI agent believes recent developments strongly suggest the bureau is preparing to lead the case, though local authorities are expected to remain involved.
Will Pima County still participate in the search?
Yes. Even if the FBI assumes control, local officers are expected to be assigned to a joint task force.
Since Feb. 1, when Nancy Guthrie was reportedly kidnapped from her home, the Pima County Sheriff’s Department has directed the search effort. Sheriff Chris Nanos previously stated that as many as 400 personnel were assigned to the case at one point, as per a report by Men's Journal.
ALSO READ: Quote of the Day by Ozzy Osbourne: 'Of all the things I've lost I miss my mind the most...'—Inspiring quotes by the 'Prince of Darkness'
However, that level of manpower is now being reduced. On Friday, the department announced that officers who had been reassigned from other units would return to their regular duties. Moving forward, only detectives specifically assigned to Guthrie’s disappearance will continue working the case unless new leads justify another surge in staffing.
ALSO READ: Quote of the Day by Russell Crowe: 'You need to learn to live with your mistakes. And you need...'—Inspiring quotes by the Gladiator actor
“This remains an active investigation and will continue until Nancy Guthrie is located or all leads have been exhausted,” a spokesperson said in a statement. “The Pima County Sheriff’s Department is refocusing resources to detectives specifically assigned to this case. As leads are developed and resolved, resource allocation may fluctuate. PCSD will maintain a patrol presence in the Guthrie neighborhood.”
The decision to scale back comes amid questions and controversy surrounding how the case has been handled. While the department remains committed, the structure of the investigation appears to be shifting, as per a report by Men's Journal.
ALSO READ: Apple March Event 2026: Date, time and how to watch in the US and UK
What signs point to FBI leadership?
According to Jennifer Coffindaffer, a retired FBI Special Agent and former SWAT Team member who now contributes to NewsNation, several recent moves suggest that federal authorities may be stepping forward to oversee the case in a task force setting.
Writing on X, Coffindaffer described the developments as “telling,” noting that the public has recently been directed to submit tips directly to the FBI rather than to local authorities. She also pointed out that the case headquarters has been moved to Phoenix.
Another noticeable change, she said, is that Sheriff Nanos has taken more of a backseat when addressing the press, relying instead on press releases and a Public Information Officer.
ALSO READ: Nancy Guthrie investigation takes dramatic turn as retired FBI agent points to a ‘big find’
The most significant moment, in her view, occurred when federal prosecutors accompanied FBI special agents to Guthrie’s home “to continue to support the investigation” into her disappearance. Coffindaffer believes this could signal that federal authorities are asserting a statute stating that if a kidnapped person is not released within 24 hours, it is presumed they may have crossed state lines, as per a report by Men's Journal.
She called the development "great news" and said it is "a pretty darn good indication" that the FBI is taking over the case.
“I think there is a certain amount of incongruency with what has gone on between the sheriff’s office, perhaps, and federal authorities. I think we’re seeing that, and perhaps in some ways, the lack of trust generally in the progress of the case because we are now almost at a month,” Coffindaffer told Newsweek. “It might be time for a change in command and, quite frankly, it might have already happened. When you see the U.S. Attorney’s Office out there, that’s a pretty darn good indication.”
Coffindaffer also indicated on social media that she believes Monday could mark the official shift in leadership.
ALSO READ: Quote of the Day by Elizabeth Taylor: 'You find out who your real friends are when...'—Inspiring quotes by the incredible actor
Will local authorities stay involved?
Even if the FBI formally assumes control, Coffindaffer expects collaboration rather than separation.
"Look for several Pima County officers to be assigned to the task force. They will stay involved, but the overarching case will be the responsibility of the FBI as discussed," Coffindaffer wrote in a post on X.
She further explained to Newsweek that cooperation between federal and local law enforcement is standard practice.
"The FBI does not like to shut out any of their state or local partners, and they're certainly not going to want to do that here. Overall, the bureau wants to work side by side with other law enforcement partners. In Pima County, those officers have the best insight regarding their territory," Coffindaffer told Newsweek.
Nancy Guthrie remains missing as of now. The Pima County Sheriff’s Department continues to call the case active, while developments suggest the FBI’s presence may soon define its next chapter.
FAQs
Is the FBI taking over the Nancy Guthrie investigation?A retired FBI agent believes recent developments strongly suggest the bureau is preparing to lead the case, though local authorities are expected to remain involved.
Will Pima County still participate in the search?
Yes. Even if the FBI assumes control, local officers are expected to be assigned to a joint task force.
