Top News

A Woman of Substance viewers 'switch off' after 'unnecessary' change
Reach Daily Express | March 12, 2026 7:39 AM CST

Brenda Blethyn's latest TV role in A Woman of Substance has finally landed on screens, but not everyone was pleased with the adaptation. The Channel 4 series is an on-screen retelling of Barbara Taylor Bradford's classic bestseller, with the beloved Vera actress starring as the older version of Emma Harte. While the actress portrays the character as a business mogul, the series kicked off with Emma's backstory as a young maid (played by Jessica Reynolds).

Although the rags-to-riches novel remains one of the top 10 bestselling books of all time, with over 91 million copies sold, fans quickly took to social media with complaints. Taking to X/Twitter, one viewer switched off, writing: "#awomanofsubstance I think I might just read the book again instead." As another noticed a major change and fumed: "Mac? MAC?!! His name isn't Mac. It's Blackie! Because of his black hair. Good grief!"

A third echoed: "Shane O'Neill (originally played by Liam Neeson) is now mysteriously nicknamed 'Mac', not Blackie. Weird and unnecessary."

While another viewer questioned: "Where is her brother Winston? Paul isn't listed in the cast either. I hope they haven't changed too much. Might have to watch the Jenny Seagrove version instead."

As a fifth repeated: "I have read all the books in the Harte series and watched the original TV mini series, so I will give this one a chance, but where is Winston?"

Despite the criticism, A Woman of Substance also gained fans, as one took to social media and praised the premiere as a "Good first episode."

** Ensure our latest showbiz headlines always appear at the top of your Google Search by making us a Preferred Source. Click here to activate or add us as Preferred Source in your Google search settings. ****

The series will follow Emma's life as an impoverished servant and her pursuit of greater ambitions, before circumstances compel her to pursue them following a series of devastating events.

The period drama will then jump to the 1970s, where Emma is a staunch mogul in charge of her own international business empire.

This isn't the first time Bradford's work has hit the screen; the first adaptation of A Woman of Substance aired on Channel 4 in 1985, featuring Jenny Seagrove, but only ran for three episodes.

Unlike the original series, the latest boasts eight instalments that will travel through time to unfold Emma's story.


READ NEXT
Cancel OK