Top News

Planet Football

·11 August 2026

Planet Football

·11 August 2026

If you follow transfer gossip columns regularly, you will be very familiar with wild tabloid claims about two major European clubs supposedly exchanging superstar footballers in a financially complex swap arrangement.

We have seen enough of these stories over the years to know that swap deals seldom actually happen, which is why it has been refreshing to see Everton and Crystal Palace complete a proper old-school arrangement with Dwight McNeil and Brennan Johnson switching clubs.

In fact, swap deals used to be far more common than they are now, and they often involved elite players at some of the biggest clubs in the game. Here is a look at 12 of the biggest swap deals in football history.

We have to put this one right at the bottom of the list, because neither player would realistically be described as a superstar.

Yes, one of them has scored the winning goal in a European final, but even so, they do not really belong in the same bracket as the footballing royalty that fills the rest of this list.

Still, we will happily take it. No ridiculous PSR loopholes, no inflated transfer fees seemingly invented out of nowhere. Just a straightforward old-fashioned swap that appears to work for everybody involved. Beautifully simple.

The one thing that really scrambles the brain is that McNeil is only one year older than Johnson. It feels as if he has been around forever, while Johnson still seems like a young rising talent in our minds. Time is a strange thing.

You cannot really mention Clarence Seedorf without also bringing up the now almost obligatory fact that he won four European Cups with three different clubs.

The midfielder had already collected two of those four by the time he went through his often-overlooked, trophyless spell in the middle of his career at Inter Milan. In 2002, the Nerazzurri made the frankly baffling choice to swap the Dutchman for Italian left wing-back Francesco Coco.

Seedorf went on to win two more Champions League titles with AC Milan, while Coco achieved very little of note at Inter and retired at the age of 30.

If you want to dig deeper into Coco’s unusual career, there is plenty to explore there.

Serie A is going to come up quite a lot here.

Italian clubs have always had a soft spot for puzzling swap deals, and few were bigger than seeing two Serie A cult figures, Diego Simeone and Christian Vieri, head in opposite directions between Lazio and Inter in the summer of 1999.

It was not a straight swap, though. Inter also paid a world-record fee of £28million, which meant the total spending on Vieri over the previous two years had reached an enormous £57million. At that point, the Italian striker accounted for three of the 10 most expensive transfers in world football.

It was at Inter where Bobo Vieri enjoyed by far the most productive and settled period of his nomadic career.

He struck 103 Serie A goals in only 143 appearances for the Nerazzurri, although remarkably he won just a single Coppa Italia during his six seasons there. Simeone, meanwhile, helped Lazio claim an unexpected Scudetto in 1999-00.

Everybody remembers that Samuel Eto’o’s move from Barcelona was crucial to Jose Mourinho building the Inter squad that went on to chase the treble in 2009-10. More on that in a moment.

Less commonly remembered is the absurdly complicated deal that brought Diego Milito and Thiago Motta from Genoa, two players who were just as important.

A young and still relatively unheralded Leonardo Bonucci went the other way along with Robert Acquafresca, Francesco Bolzoni and Riccardo Meggiorini, while the co-ownership registration rights of the now largely forgotten Montenegrin striker Ivan Fatic were also part of the arrangement.

We could try to break down every detail of that deal, but it would need an accountant. In any case, Inter clearly came out on top, going on to win the Coppa Italia, the Serie A title and the Champions League.

Genoa did not even get the benefit of Bonucci, who was sold immediately to Bari without making a single appearance for the club.

The late great Jose Antonio Reyes returned to Spain in 2006 after a couple of memorable seasons with Arsenal. This was that rarer thing, a loan swap deal.

Reyes spent one season at Real Madrid, scoring seven goals, providing four assists and winning the La Liga title.

At Arsenal, Julio Baptista scored 10 goals, including four in one match against Liverpool, and added four assists for the Gunners, but he did not win any silverware.

The following summer, both players were back in the Spanish capital, with Baptista returning to his parent club and Reyes joining Atletico Madrid, the city rivals of Los Blancos.

It does play tricks with the mind that Ashley Cole won more Premier League titles with Arsenal than he did with Chelsea.

Surprisingly, England’s long-serving left-back actually lifted only one league title during his eight years at Stamford Bridge.

Yet he still completed the full set there, winning the Champions League, the Europa League, the League Cup and no fewer than four FA Cups, adding those to the three he had already won with the Gunners.

Needless to say, William Gallas came nowhere close to matching that at the Emirates, where his most enduring legacy is probably that infamous sit-down protest during an intense title race.

At least Arsenal also got a transfer fee of £5million. Oof.

This was a proper mid-2000s player swap. You can almost imagine Razorlight’s Golden Touch playing nearby while people read about it in a newspaper or on the slowly loading pages of a desktop PC using ethernet.

After failing to make the grade at Barcelona, who reportedly chose to sign him instead of Cristiano Ronaldo, Ricardo Quaresma returned to Portugal to join the reigning European champions Porto.

Deco, fresh from starring in Mourinho’s unforgettable Porto side, went the other way and proved just as influential for Barcelona as they won back-to-back La Liga titles and the Champions League in 2006.

Porto also received £13million along with Quaresma, which sounds about right.

We all remember the piano unveiling video and Alexis Sanchez going from one of the Premier League’s most dangerous forwards to a pale imitation of himself after leaving Arsenal for Manchester United.

What is easier to forget is Henrikh Mkhitaryan moving the other way, with the Armenian winger producing a second successive thoroughly underwhelming Premier League spell in what was otherwise a more than respectable career.

Reports at the time suggested Sanchez cost United £35million, while Mkhitaryan cost Arsenal a similar figure. It was one of those rare deals that ended up leaving everybody rather unhappy.

When cult hero Luis Garcia left Liverpool for Atletico Madrid, the player arriving in return was a genuine Anfield icon in the making, Fernando Torres.

It was reported that Liverpool paid Atletico an additional £21.5million, plus Garcia, to secure the signing of their prized academy graduate.

Torres incredibly failed to win any silverware during his time on Merseyside, but he immediately established himself as one of the deadliest strikers in the country. His goals were a major reason Rafael Benitez’s side became real title challengers in 2008-09.

It is slightly strange to think that two players who would later line up together at Stamford Bridge, both during their second spells at Chelsea, had once moved in opposite directions in the same deal.

But when Chelsea first signed David Luiz from Benfica in 2011, they included the young fringe player Nemanja Matic as part of the package.

The Brazilian defender helped the Blues win the Champions League in his first season, and across his two spells he also collected two Europa Leagues, two FA Cups and one Premier League title. Matic, meanwhile, developed significantly at the Estadio da Luz before eventually returning to Chelsea in 2014.

This one is huge mainly because of the staggering fees attached to it. Arthur is officially Barcelona’s second-most expensive sale, joining Juventus for €80million, while Miralem Pjanic still sits among Barcelona’s top 10 record signings thanks to a fee of €60million.

Pjanic is now a free agent after spending two years with UAE club Sharjah. Arthur remains at Juventus, but he is not part of their plans after loan spells with Liverpool and Fiorentina.

That says plenty about the direction of both careers after that 2020 swap deal, and also about how inflated those fees were even at the time.

It was just daft. But it also served as an important early example of this bewildering new era of “pure profit” and PSR workaround transfers. Bring back Jim White and his yellow tie; this kind of nonsense would never have happened in his day.

Now for the biggest one of all. It would be a real surprise if we ever again see two players of this stature move in opposite directions.

Eto’o went on to win a second straight treble with Inter, which is an utterly absurd achievement when you stop to think about it.

Zlatan Ibrahimovic won La Liga and scored a respectable 22 goals in 46 appearances during his single season at Camp Nou, but he famously did not see eye to eye with Pep Guardiola and was back in Serie A after only one year, initially joining Inter’s rivals AC Milan on loan.

Inter unquestionably came out on top in this one. And that is before even considering the extra fee, which varies depending on the source but is believed to have been as much as €69.5 million. Wooooof.7