Top News

The growing concerns around the U.S. government’s H-1B visa policies and the potential implications for skilled Indian professionals have prompted widespread discussions about the future of India’s tech workforce and the global flow of talent. With the Trump administration’s decision to impose a hefty $100,000 fee on H-1B visa applications, the once-lucrative route for foreign workers, particularly those from India, is becoming increasingly difficult to navigate. Indian tech professionals, who make up nearly 70% of all H-1B visa holders, are beginning to feel the heat, as the policy shift has created uncertainty regarding their long-term careers in the U.S. The sentiment against H-1B workers, especially in the tech sector, has also been rising, making their stay in the U.S. more untenable with every passing day.

For many Indians, the allure of studying in the U.S. and subsequently finding a job in the country has long been a clear and attainable dream. With tighter H-1B restrictions, this dream is now being compromised.

This development echoes a scenario observed in China, where, for years, thousands of students and tech professionals have returned home after their studies or professional stints abroad. Known as the "sea turtles," these individuals have played a pivotal role in transforming China’s technological landscape, thanks to policies that encouraged their return.

Could India follow China’s lead and devise a similar plan to reverse the brain drain and convert the challenges posed by the H-1B clampdown into an opportunity for national growth? While the concept holds promise, the implementation would require overcoming several unique challenges.

(Join our ETNRI WhatsApp channel for all the latest updates)


Also Read | China silent on US H-1B visa hike, but opens doors to global talent

The Chinese "Sea Turtle" model
China’s successful efforts to lure back its highly skilled expatriates, especially in the fields of STEM, can provide important lessons for India. The Chinese government implemented ambitious programs like the Thousand Talents Plan, which offered enticing incentives such as research grants, tax breaks, housing subsidies and easier visa permits for high-level talent returning from abroad. These measures targeted returnees, also known as "sea turtles," who had acquired foreign degrees and professional experience, particularly in the tech, research and manufacturing sectors. By offering significant support in the form of grants, high salaries and conducive working environments, China not only incentivised its citizens abroad to come back but also created an ecosystem where returnees could thrive.

The results were impressive. Many Chinese returnees contributed significantly to the modernisation of China’s manufacturing and tech sectors, especially in the fields of internet technology, artificial intelligence (AI), biotechnology and engineering. Their expertise helped shift China from being a labour-intensive economy to a powerhouse in advanced manufacturing and high-tech industries. The returnees’ international networks and global business experience opened up new avenues for Chinese firms to expand globally, while their leadership in universities and research institutions bolstered China’s position in cutting-edge fields like space exploration, medicine and engineering.

China’s economic boom, rapid industrialisation and reform period created a conducive environment for these "sea turtles" to return and contribute to the country’s rise. As a result, China not only retained a significant portion of its talent but also turned the brain drain into a major driver of national economic growth.

Also Read | America’s loss, Europe’s gain? The scramble for Indian talent

Can India replicate this Chinese model?
India stands at a unique crossroads. With the Modi government’s emphasis on economic reforms, manufacturing, technology and innovation, the country is increasingly looking to position itself as a global economic and tech powerhouse. India’s tech landscape is flourishing, with over 100 unicorns and more than 1.5 lakh startups. The Indian government has launched numerous initiatives, such as Make in India, Startup India, Digital India and PLIs, all of which aim to drive innovation and entrepreneurship.

However, despite these encouraging developments, India faces significant challenges in creating an ecosystem that can compete with the likes of Silicon Valley. While the country has abundant talent, it still struggles with a lack of deep-rooted innovation culture, risk-taking tendencies and supportive infrastructures like funding, venture capital and mentorship that enable startups to scale. The Indian tech ecosystem, though large, still lacks the density and dynamism seen in global innovation hubs like the U.S. or China.

India’s potential to replicate China’s "sea turtle" model, therefore, depends on its ability to address these gaps and create a more attractive environment for returnees.

India needs to cultivate an ecosystem where risk-taking, entrepreneurship and innovation are encouraged at every level. While tech hubs like Bengaluru, Hyderabad and Gurugram have emerged as centers for startups, these cities still struggle with challenges like inconsistent infrastructure, regulatory hurdles, limited access to early-stage funding and civic problems.

The Indian government must go beyond offering symbolic incentives. This includes tax breaks, research grants, housing subsidies and streamlined visa processes for expatriates returning from abroad, similar to China’s Thousand Talents Plan. The government needs to establish long-term policies that foster a conducive environment for global talent to return, not just in terms of financial incentives but also in terms of governance, legal frameworks and transparency.

While India’s startup ecosystem is growing, the country still ranks low in global ease-of-doing-business indices. Tackling bureaucracy, reducing regulatory burden, and creating a smoother path for entrepreneurs to launch and scale businesses will be crucial for attracting skilled professionals back home.

The venture capital landscape in India is growing, but it still lags far behind that of the U.S. and China in terms of capital infusion and risk appetite. Indian policymakers must work on creating funding mechanisms that can compete with global standards, encouraging both domestic and foreign investments in high-risk, high-reward projects.

India should also promote greater collaboration between its universities, research institutions and startups with those abroad. By establishing research programs and joint ventures that allow returnees to collaborate with global peers, India can leverage international expertise while also promoting domestic innovation.

The ongoing H-1B visa situation could, in theory, present India with a unique opportunity to build its own talent pipeline. By creating policies that support the return of skilled professionals, India can accelerate its journey toward becoming a global innovation leader. However, this vision will only materialise if India addresses the structural, policy and cultural challenges that continue to stymie its growth.