Top News

When Vaibhav Sooryavanshi made his India debut, it was a moment steeped in symbolism. The teenage sensation was handed his maiden cap by Tilak Varma the third-youngest member of the squad rather than legends like Farokh Engineer, Gautam Gambhir, or Sanju Samson, who were all present at Old Trafford that day. The choice surprised many, but it also spoke volumes about how highly the team management rates Tilak. Just weeks earlier, Tilak had been named India's T20I vice-captain ahead of more experienced candidates like Axar Patel, Ishan Kishan, and Sanju Samson.

He was also appointed India A captain, with head coach Gautam Gambhir's clear message: "Whenever you lead India A, keep this in mind that you have to do that for India also." The vice-captaincy effectively granted him immunity from being dropped a privilege that has become increasingly hard to justify. The Numbers Tell a Worrying Story: On the surface, Tilak's T20I record looks impressive. Since the start of 2025, he has scored the most runs (899) among non-openers in T20 internationals. But a deeper dive reveals a glaring flaw his strike rate of 131.62 is the fifth-worst among the 16 players with at least 500 runs in this period.

This wasn't always the case. In 2023-2024, Tilak was the seventh-highest run-scorer among non-openers with an excellent strike rate of 161.25. The sharp 30-point decline stems almost entirely from his growing struggles against spin a weakness that has become increasingly pronounced over the past two years. IPL Data Exposes the Problem: Using a 'batting impact' metric which measures runs in context of match situations the numbers paint a bleak picture.

In the last two IPL seasons, Tilak ranks in the 55th percentile against pace (better than 55% of non-openers) but plummets to just the 24th percentile against spin. In IPL 2026, he recorded a negative impact-per-ball against spinners for the first time, meaning his batting actually hurt Mumbai Indians' chances of winning whenever he faced spin. While the average left-hander in the IPL struck 23% of his balls for boundaries in 2026, Tilak's boundary-hitting has dropped significantly. Worryingly, this issue isn't confined to any specific type of spinner it's a universal struggle that has eroded his effectiveness. What This Means for India: Tilak is undoubtedly a talented cricketer with a strong domestic pedigree.

But his vice-captaincy feels premature when his core weakness spin-playing ability remains unaddressed. In a T20 setup that demands intent and impact, a strike rate of 131.62 and a negative impact against spin are simply not good enough for a player entrusted with leadership responsibilities. If India are serious about building a world-class T20 side, they need to either help Tilak fix his spin troubles or reconsider his role and certainly his vice-captaincy until he proves he can deliver when it matters most.