Rookie Misiorowski Makes All-Star Team After 5 Games \ TezzBuzz \ Washington DC \ Mary Sidiqi \ Evening Edition \ Milwaukee Brewers rookie Jacob Misiorowski’s All-Star selection has sparked heated debate due to his limited MLB experience. National League manager Dave Roberts defended the pick, citing fan excitement and future potential. While some players voiced support, others believe veteran pitchers were unfairly left out.
Quick Looks
- Jacob Misiorowski named an All-Star after just five MLB appearances
- Dave Roberts defends pick, calling it an “easy answer”
- Rookie right-hander throws 100+ mph and boasts a 2.81 ERA
- Phillies’ Trea Turner calls selection “a joke” amid snubs
- Phillies pushed for Cristopher Sánchez and Ranger Suárez instead
- Misiorowski says he’s just honored and surprised by the nod
- Kyle Schwarber supports Misiorowski while defending Phillies’ snubbed pitchers
- Roberts plans to use Misiorowski as early as the fifth inning
- Clayton Kershaw and Robbie Ray praised the rookie’s talent
- All-Star selection seen as fan-focused exhibition by Brian Snitker
Deep Look
Milwaukee Brewers rookie Jacob Misiorowski’s stunning All-Star Game selection after just five big-league appearances has sparked widespread discussion across Major League Baseball. The 23-year-old flamethrower, known for topping 100 mph, has become the center of a debate pitting tradition against spectacle — and resume against raw talent.
National League manager Dave Roberts of the Los Angeles Dodgers stood firmly behind the controversial pick, calling Misiorowski’s inclusion an “easy answer.” Speaking before Monday’s Home Run Derby, Roberts framed the decision as one driven by both performance and entertainment. “If it brings excitement, attention to our game, then I’m all about it,” he said.
Roberts acknowledged the dual nature of the All-Star Game: a celebration of both the league’s top talent and a fan-driven showcase. “My North Star is that the All-Star Game should feature the game’s best players,” he said. “But it’s also about the fans and what they want to see.”
A Record-Low Experience for an All-Star
Misiorowski has pitched just 25 2/3 innings in the majors, the fewest ever for a player selected as an All-Star. His five-game sample is undeniably impressive: a 4-1 record, 2.81 ERAand 33 strikeouts while allowing just 12 hits. His first pitch in the majors clocked in at 100.5 mph, and he debuted with five no-hit innings against St. Louis before exiting due to cramping in a 6-0 Brewers win on June 12.
Despite those stats, some veteran players feel that more established pitchers deserved the nod. Trea Turner of the Phillies was particularly vocal, saying, “What a joke,” after Misiorowski’s selection left teammates Cristopher Sánchez (8-2, 2.50 ERA) and Ranger Suárez (7-3, 1.94 ERA) off the roster.
Misiorowski Responds with Grace
Misiorowski, for his part, has handled the scrutiny with maturity. “They’re not upset with me,” he said Monday. “The last five weeks have been insane. I thought the All-Star break would be a chance to sit down and reflect. Now we’re here.”
His approach has earned respect, even from critics. Phillies slugger Kyle Schwarberan All-Star himself, clarified that the team’s frustration wasn’t directed at Misiorowski. “It’s not his fault that he’s only pitched five games and got named,” Schwarber said. He added that Misiorowski deserves the honor and predicted a bright future: “He’s going to be a perennial All-Star.”
Schwarber also noted the dilemma players face when deserving teammates get snubbed: “Our guys had some really good years… you want them to feel like they’re going to get represented the way that they should be.”
Managerial Praise Across the League
Roberts confirmed plans to bring Misiorowski into the game as early as the fifth inning, promising “it’s going to be electric.” Veteran Dodgers left-hander Clayton Kershawnamed to his 11th All-Star Game as a “legend pick” by Commissioner Rob Manfred, supported the idea of including the league’s top talent, no matter their experience. “Everybody wants the best players here,” he said.
Robbie Raya 33-year-old San Francisco pitcher, praised Misiorowski’s talent. “He’s got an electric arm. He’s a special talent, and I’m excited to watch him pitch.”
Braves manager Brian Snitkerserving on Roberts’ staff, echoed those thoughts. “It’s an exhibition game,” he said. “There are some guys that are very deserving. It is what it is. He’s another great talent.”
All-Star Game or Marketing Event?
The selection has reignited a long-standing debate: Is the All-Star Game about merit or marketability? While many believe that consistent, season-long performance should dictate All-Star inclusion, others argue that unique, buzzworthy players like Misiorowski energize the sport and capture the imagination of fans.
Whether this moment marks the beginning of a trend or remains a one-off exception, Misiorowski’s place in Atlanta is set. The spotlight will shine bright when the National League rookie takes the mound — five games into what could become a legendary career.
More on Sports
Rookie Misiorowski Makes
